To help you find the perfect options, we spoke with Foley for buying tips, then researched and tested today’s best-selling models. The Boll & Branch Mattress is our favorite pick based on our findings. It earned top marks from our home tester and stands out for its soft yet supportive design and eco-friendly construction. Here are the best innerspring mattresses available today. Unlike the innerspring mattresses of decades past, this one boasts individually wrapped foundation coils, plus over 2,000 encased micro-coils to offer full-body support and isolate movement. While our tester said the springs do a great job preventing motion transfer, she mentioned that they make a little noise when climbing on. The Mattress is hand-assembled from ethically sourced, sustainable materials and backed by a ten-year warranty. While the price is pretty steep, you can count on quality and long-lasting comfort. The upper layers consist of a cotton pad, egg carton foam, high-density memory foam, and bamboo fabric. As an inherently breathable material with natural cooling abilities, the bamboo helps you stay at a comfy temperature throughout the night. While it’s unavailable in twin XL or California king sizes, unlike many other innerspring models, this mattress comes in compressed packaging, making it easier to move into your room of choice. Next, there’s a layer of CertiPUR-US-certified memory foam, and on top, you’ve got quilted padding. Lastly, a stretchy knitted Tencel cover helps wick away sweat while you doze. Aside from the price, the only other potential downside of this mattress is that you’ll need an extra-deep fitted sheet since it’s thicker than average. Then there’s a 2-inch layer of high-density foam for additional support, followed by 1 inch of copper-infused memory foam for a cooling effect. The minimally padded top layer is also firm. This hybrid mattress comes in a compressed box, which makes it easy to carry to your bedroom, but it takes about a day to expand. The layers include a dual-coil base with high-density foam rails to prevent sagging and responsive pocketed coils designed to contour to your curves. Just above, there’s CertiPUR-US-certified memory foam, followed by a quilted pillow top with an organic cotton cover. Though this mattress doesn’t isolate movement, and there’s a fee if you return it, you can’t beat the lifetime warranty. Above the base, a thin layer of gel-infused memory foam provides a cooling effect while conforming to the shape of your spine to encourage natural alignment and reduce discomfort at your pressure points. The top is thinly quilted, with sturdy edge support all around. Though this mattress might be too firm for folks who sleep on their sides, it’s ideal for those who doze on their backs with minimal tossing and turning. Following these layers is a slightly thicker wool pad for more breathable insulation and another layer of individually wrapped micro-coils designed to isolate movement and conform to the shape of your body. Atop these layers is one more wool pad and quilted organic cotton. There’s a lot to love about this thoughtfully designed mattress—we only wish it were more affordable. Above the coils is 3 inches of certified-organic latex rubber to provide full-body support with medium firmness. The top layer is ethically sourced tufted wool that’s not only organic but also Oeko-Tex certified to ensure it’s safe for you and the planet. While the standard version is likely too firm for most side sleepers, there’s also a pillow-top option that should be more comfortable for the hips. Next, you’ve got gel-infused foam, which offers a cooling effect, then open-cell foam that encourages breathability by allowing air to pass through. On top is a naturally sourced Tencel fabric with Beautyrest’s cool-to-the-touch technology, plus edge support all around. One drawback is that since this mattress is 15 inches thick (or 16 inches with a pillowtop), you’ll need a fitted sheet with extra-deep pockets. Otherwise, this mattress could offer the ideal blend of cooling and support for more comfortable sleep. Most of today’s models are hybrid mattresses, meaning they feature additional layers above the coils, such as memory foam, latex, wool, or a pillow-top fabric. These materials can offer extra support, enhanced plushness, or a cooling effect.
Firmness
While Foley says innerspring mattresses tend to be firmer generally, she says that “choosing the right [one] is personal to the buyer.” Firm models are considered ideal for those who sleep on their backs, and medium-firm options work well for most sleeping positions. Softer mattresses are often preferred by side sleepers, as they help alleviate pressure on the hips.
Thickness
You also want to consider the thickness. Innerspring mattresses range from about ten inches to 15 inches deep. Thicker options aren’t necessarily more comfortable, plus they’re usually pricier and call for an extra-deep fitted sheet. However, they often consist of more layers to provide benefits like temperature regulation or pressure-point relief.
Why Trust The Spruce?
Theresa Holland is a freelance writer specializing in home design within the commerce space. A contributor at The Spruce since 2019, Theresa covers furniture, bedding, and sleep products. Foley explains that modern innerspring mattresses typically feature individually wrapped springs (also known as pocketed coils). “These coils are not connected, which results in more motion isolation and airflow,” she notes. For this story, she interviewed Logan Foley, a Certified Sleep Science Coach and Managing Editor at Sleepfoundation.org, who provided expertise on the features and benefits of innerspring mattresses. She also looked at insights from home-tested and lab-tested models, then researched today’s best-sellers, considering the material, firmness, thickness, and overall value of dozens of options before narrowing down the top picks.
